Rating Summaries

Each episode we rate one (and sometimes 2) games on the Blue Peg, Pink Peg rating system.

0 Pegs = Burn It, 1 Peg = Avoid It, 2 Pegs = Not Horrible, 3 Pegs = Worth Playing, 4 Pegs = Worth Owning, 5 Pegs = A Collection Asset, 6 Pegs = A Collection Essential.

Reviewers: C = Christina, J =  Jeremy, R = Robb, P = Patrick, Jo = Josh, Guest = Guest reviewer.

Click on any of the game titles to see when the game has appeared in the show.

Ep.	Game	Average	Reroll	Chr.	Robb.	Bran.	Kev.	Jer.	Pat.	Jo.	Guest
262	Zhanguo: The First Empire	3.75	n/a	3	4	4	4
261	Nucleum	3.5	n/a	3	4		5		3
260	Kutna Hora - The City of Silver	3.75	n/a	4	4	5	2
259	Cuzco	4.625	n/a	4	5/6	4	5
258	Federation	4.75	n/a	5	5	5	4
256	Planta Nubo	3.75	n/a	3	4	4	4
255	Amritsar	3	n/a	3	4	3	2
254	Evacuation	4.125	n/a	4	3/4	5	4
253	Dead By Daylight	2.75	n/a	3	2	3	3
251	Thunder Road: Vendetta	4.25	n/a	5	4	4	4
250	Hegemony- Lead Your Class to Victory	4.125	n/a	1/4	3/5	5	5
249	Galaxy Trucker (2nd ed)	4.25	(kind of this rating)	6	4	4	3
248	3 Ring Circus	3.25	n/a	3	3	4	3
247	The Witcher: Old World	2.75	n/a	3	3	3	2
246	Tiletum	5	n/a	5	5	5	5
245	Atiwa	3.75	n/a	4	2	5	4
244	Darwin's Journey	5	n/a	5	5	5	5
243	Flamecraft	4	n/a	4	4	4	4
242	Revive	4.75	n/a	5	5	4	5
241	Earth	4.75	n/a	5	4	5	5
240	Carnegie	5	n/a	5	5	5	5
239	Northgard: Uncharted Lands	2.875	n/a	3	2/3	3	3
238	Endless Winter: Paleoamericans	3.5	n/a	3	4	3	4
237	Clank! Catacombs	4.25	n/a	5	4	4	4
236	Marrakesh	5.25	n/a	5	6	5	5
235	Lacrimosa	3.125	n/a	3	3/4	3	3
234	Azul: Queen's Garden	4	n/a	4	4	4	4
233	Twilight Inscription	3.5	n/a	5	4	3	2
232	Mosiac	4.5	n/a	4	5	4	5
231	Skymines	4.75	n/a	4	5	5	5
230	Rear Window	2.75	n/a	3	3	3	2
229	Nemesis	4.5	n/a	5	4	5	4
228	Nidavellir	4	n/a	4	5	3	4
227	Terracotta Army	5	n/a	5	5	5	5
226	Brazil Imperial	3.5	n/a	3	4	4	3
225	Castles of Tuscany	3.625	n/a	4	3	3/4	4
224	Ark Nova	5.25	n/a	5	5	5	6
223	Underwater Cities	5.25	n/a	5	5	6	5
222	Gutenberg	3.75	n/a	3	4	4	4
221	Dead Reckoning	5	n/a	5	5		5		5
220	Golem	3	n/a	3	4	3	2
219	Wonderlands War	4.5	n/a	4	5	4	5
218	Founders of Teotihuacan	3.25	n/a	4	2	4	3
217	Tenpenny Park	3.75	n/a	4	4	4	3
216	Libertalia: Winds of Galecrest	4.75	n/a	4	5	5	5
215	Lizard Wizard	3.75	n/a	3	3	4	5
214	Tabannusi	3	n/a	3	3	3	3
213	Gaia Project	5	n/a	4	6	5	5
212	Corrosion	4.25	n/a	4	4	4	5
211	Bitoku	5.00	flat	5	5			5
210	Cape May	4.25	n/a	4	4						Ilya - 5 Tyler - 4
209	Dinosaur World	3.5	down	4	3						TJ - 3 Richmond - 4
208	Oink Game Suite	5.25	flat	5	5						Ambie - 6 Crystal - 5
207	Kokopelli	3.25	flat	3	4		3		3
206	Unfathomable	3.25	down	4/2	3		4		3
205	The Night Cage	2.33	down	3	2	2
203	Red Rising	4.00	down	5	4	3	4
202	Too Many Bones	4.67	down	4	4						Danielle - 6
201	Ankh: Gods of Egypt	3.33	down	4	3				3
201	Terraforming Mars: Ares Expedition	4.00	up	5	4	5			2
200	The Initiative	4.88	down	5	5						David - 5; Elisha - 4.5
199	Embarcadero	4.00	down	4	4			4
198	City Builder: Ancient World	4.00	flat	4	4			4
197	Dominant Species: Marine	3.33	down	3	4			4
196	Ginkgopolis	5.67	flat	5	6			6
195	After the Empire	2.67	flat	4	2			2
194	Excavation Earth	2.67	flat	3	2			3
193	Almanac: The Dragon Road	3.67	down	4	4			3
192	Merv: The Heart of the Silk Road	4.33	flat	4	4			5
191	Hallertau	4.00	flat	4	4			4
190	Praga Caput Regni	5.33	down	5	6			5
189	Paris	3.00	flat	3	3			3
188	Bonfire	4.67	flat	5	5			4
187	Alma Mater	2.87	down	3	4/3			2	3
186	Dune: Imperium	4.75	flat		5			5	5		David - 4
185	Beyond the Sun	3.67	up	3	4			4
184	Lost Ruins of Arnak	3.33	flat	3	4			3
183	Tekhenu: Obelisk of the Sun	5.00	flat	5	5			5	5
182	Apocrypha: Adventure Card Game	2.00	down	3/1	4			3
181	Greenville 1989	4.5	down	5	3/4			5			Tara - 4/5
180	Trismegistus: The Ultimate Formula	4.00	flat		4			3	5
179	Ecos: The First Continent	5.67	flat	5	6			6
178	Vindication	5.00	n/a	5	5				5
177	Forgotten Waters	3.67	Flat	3	4			4
176	Glen More II: Chronicles	4.67	n/a	5	5			4
175	Godspeed	3.67	n/a	3	4			4
174	Nevada City	5.00	down	5	5			5
173	Trickerion	4.00	flat	4	4			4
172	Reavers of Midgard	6.00	down	6	6			6
171	Egizia: Shifting Sands	3.33	down	4	3			3
170	Paladins of the West Kingdom	5.00	down	4	5			6
169	Caylus	3.66	down	4	3			4
168	Cooper Island	4.83	flat	5	4/5			5
167	7 Souls	3.75	down	4	3			5	3
166	Oceans	3.33	flat	4	4			2
165	Sierra West	3.00	flat	3	3			3
164	Isle of Cats	3.67	flat	4	4			3
163	Sorcerer City	4.66	flat	6	4			4
162	Maracaibo	4.00	flat	4	5			2	5
161	The Taverns of Tiefenthal	4.33	flat	5	4			4
160	A War of Whispers	3.00	down	3	3			3
159	Rune Stones	4.00	flat	4	5			3
158	Flotilla	4.66	down	4	5			5
157	Abomination: Heir of Frankenstein	2.66	flat	3	3			2
156	Horrified	4.50	down	4	5			5		4
155	Rurik	4.00	flat	5	4			3
154	Dead Man's Cabal	4.00	flat	4	4			4
153	The Artemis Project	3.50	flat	4	4			3	3
152	Chronicles of Crime	4.75	flat	5	4			6	4
151	Rolled West	3.75	flat	4	3			4	4
151	Lanterns Dice	3.00	flat	4	3			2	3
151	Cartographers	5.00	flat	5	5			5	5
150	Pipeline	3.75	down	4	3			4	4
148	Journeys in Middle Earth	4.00	down	4	4			4	4
147	Gentes	4.50	flat	5	4			5	4
146	Tiny Towns	3.13	down	3	3/4			3	3
145	Tudor	2.75	flat	2	3			2	4
144	Treasure Island	2.75	down	4	2			3	2
143	Forum Trajanum	3.25	flat	3	4			2	4
142	Teotihuacan: City of Gods	4.75	flat	6	4			5	4
141	Gugong	3.00	up	4	3			2	3
140	Just One	5.33	up		5				5		Bruce - 6
140	But Wait, There's More!	4.67	down		5				4		Bruce - 5
140	Pantone	1.67	down		2				1		Bruce - 2
139	Quacks of Quedlinburg	4.00	up	5	4			3	4
138	Blackout: Hong Kong	4.75	down	5	5			4	5
137	Coimbra	6.00	down	6	6			6	6		Danny - 6
136	Pulsar 2849	4.40	flat	5	4			4	4		David - 5
135	Porta Nigra	4.30	flat	4	4			5	4		James - 4/5
134	Feudum	4.50	flat	4	5			5	4
133	The Thing: Infection at Outpost 31	2.50	down	3	3			2	2
132	Nyctophobia: Vampire Encounter	3.25	flat	4	1			5	3
132	Sub Terra	2.50	flat	3	2/4			2	2
131	Detective: A Modern Crime Board Game	4.67	down	6	4				4
130	Root	4.33	down	4	4				5
129	Gunkimono	3.67	flat	4	4				3
129	Expancity	4.00	flat	4	4				4
129	Spring Meadow	2.67	flat	4	2				2
128	Petrichor	3.33	down	3	4				3
127	Thunderstone Quest	5.00	down	4	5				5	6
126	Carthago	3.25	flat	3	4				3	3
125	Crystal Clans	4.25	down	4	5				4	4
125	The Fox in the Forest	3.25	down	3	4				3	3
125	Santorini	3.50	flat	4	3				5	2
124	Argent: The Consortium	5.00	down	4	5				5	5
123	Trajan	5.00	flat	5	5				6	4
122	Altiplano	3.75	flat	4	4				4	3
121	Heroes of Land, Sea and Air	4.00	flat	4	4				4	4
120	Dinosaur Island	4.00	down	4	3				3	2
119	Rising Sun	5.00	down	5	5				5	5
118	Clans of Caledonia	4.40	down	4/5	4				5	4
117	Calimala	4.00	flat	4	5				4	3
116	Raiders of the North Sea	4.00	flat	4	4				4	4
115	Rajas of the Ganges	3.75	flat	4	4				4	3
114	Lisboa	5.00	flat	4	5				6
113	Stuffed Fables	4.33	down	4	3/5				5		Rodney - 3/5
112	Whistle Stop	4.20	down	4	4				5		Marty & Tony - 4
111	Valletta	2.88	down	3	3				2		Stephanie - 3/4
110	Custom Heroes	5.67	flat	6	6				5
110	Trickster: Champion of Time	5.00	flat	5	5				5
110	Indulgence	3.33	down	3	3				4
109	Mansions of Madness 2nd. Ed	5.00	up	5	5			6	4
108	Fate of the Elder Gods	4.50	flat	4	4			5	5
107	Ex Libris	3.33	down	4				3	3
106	Lorenzo il Magnifico	4.25	flat	4	4			5	4
104	Sentient	4.50	flat	5	4			5	4
103	Wasteland Express Delivery Service	5.00	down	4	5			6	5
102	Barenpark	3.00	down	3	2/4			3	3
99	Aeon's End	3.50	flat	4	4			2	4
98	Yokohama	4.75	flat	5	4			5	5
97	Viticulture	4.80	flat	4	4			5	5		Peghead Sean - 6
96	Railroad Revolution	4.50	down	5	4			5	4
94	Adrenaline	2.88	down	3	2/3			3	3
93	Clank!	4.75	flat	5	4			5	5
92	Barcelona: The Rose of Fire	4.50	flat	4	4			5	5
91	Manhattan Project: Energy Empire	4.00	down	4	3			2	5		Peghead Steve - 6
90	The Oracle of Delphi	3.50	down	4	4			3	3
89	Great Western Trail	4.25	up	4	4			5	4
88	Tikal	4.40	flat	4	3			4	5		Peghead Tahsin - 4
87	Haspelknecht	3.25	down	3	3			3	4
86	Terraforming Mars	5.50	up	6	5			6	5
85	Mystic Vale	4.50	flat	5	4			5	4
84	The Others	3.50	flat	4	4			3	3
83	Salem	3.25	down	3	2/4			4	3
82	Scythe	3.75	up	4	3			5	3
81	Inis	3.75	down	4	4			3	4
80	Cry Havoc	4.00	flat	4	4			3	5
79	Junk Art	3.75	down	4	4			2	5
78	My Village	3.75	flat	4	4			3	4
77	Millennium Blades	4.75	flat	4	5			5	5
76	The Networks	3.25	down	4	2			3	4
75	Isle of Skye	4.00	up	5	4			4	3
74	Antarctica	4.00	down	4	3			5	4
73	Seven Wonders: Duel	2.75	up	4	2			3	2
73	The Rose King	4.75	flat	5	5			5	4
73	Thunder & Lightning	4.75	up	4	5			4	6
73	Tides of Time	3.00	down	1	3			3	5
72	Castles of Burgundy	5.66	up	6	5			n/a	6
71	The Prodigals Club	5.00	down	5				5	5
70	Mombasa	4.50	up	4	4			5	5
69	Shakespeare	2.55	down	3	3			2	2
68	Grand Austria Hotel	3.94	down	4	3/4			4	4
67	Kingdom Death: Monster	2.75	flat	4	5			0	2
66	Dark Moon	4.50	flat	4	3			6	5
65	Orleans	4.25	up	4	4			4	5
64	Tail Feathers	3.25	down	3	2			4	4
63	Star Wars: Imperial Assault	4.00	flat	4	4			4	4
62	The Golden Ages	3.25	flat	3	3			3	4
61	Pandemic Legacy: Season 1	4.50	down	5	3/5			4	5
60	Above and Below	4.00	down	4	3			5	4
59	Dark, Darker, Darkest	1.25	down	1	2			2	0
58	Dead of Winter	4.25	down	4	4			5	4
57	Blood Rage	4.50	flat	4	4			5	5
56	Rattle, Battle, Grab the Loot	2.00	flat	2	2			2	2
55	Viceroy	3.00	n/a	3	3			3	3
54	La Granja	5.25	flat	5	4			6	6
53	Eysium	3.38	down	4	3/4			2	4
52	[redacted]	1.75	flat	2	1			2	2
51	Terra Mystica	5.25	up	4	6			5	6
50	Staufer Dynasty	4.44	down	5	3/4			4	5
49	Panamax	4.00	down	3	4			5	4
48	Murano	3.25	flat	3	3			3	4
47	Pathfinder ACG	2.63	up	3	2/5			1	3
47	Descent 2nd Ed.	3.50	down	3	4			3	4
46	Patchistory	4.33	up		4			4	4
45	St. Petersburg	4.25	flat	4	4			5	4
44	Deus	4.00	up	4	4			3	5
43	Castles of Mad King Ludwig	4.75	flat	6	5			2	6
42	CO2	4.00	flat	4	4			4	4
41	Scoville	3.25	down	3	2/4			4	3
40	Kingsport Festival	3.25	down	3	2			5	3
39	Chimera	4.25	flat	4	4			3	6
39	Diamonds	4.50	down	4	4			5	5
38	Concordia	4.25	up	3	4			5	5
37	Abyss	3.75	flat	3	4			4	4
36	Legacy: The Testament of Duke de Crecy	3.50	flat	3	4			3	4
35	Battle at Kemble's Cascade	4.00	down	4	4/2				5		Keri - 4
34	Fiasco	3.50	up	4	4				3		Keri - 3
34	Elder Sign	3.00	up	3	3				3		Keri - 3
33	Zombie 15	1.33	flat		1				1		Keri - 2
32	Among the Stars	3.75	flat	4	4				4		Keri - 2/4
31	Five Tribes	5.00	up	5	4				6		Keri - 5
30	Machi Koro	3.25	down	3	2				4		Keri - 4
30	Pandemic Contagion	2.75	flat	3	2				3		Keri - 3
29	Enigma	3.5	up	4	1/4				4		Keri - 5
29	Macao	3.750	flat	4	5				3		Keri - 3
28	Instanbul	3.250	flat	2	3				4		Keri - 4
27	Splendor	3.58	up	4	3/4				3		Keri - 4
27	Blueprints	3.00	down	3	3				3		Keri - 3
26	Blue Moon Legends	5.00	tbd	5	4				5		Keri - 6
25	Sentinels of the Multiverse	2.63	tbd	1/4	2				3		Keri - 2
24	Bruxelles 1893	4.50	tbd	4	5				5		Keri - 4
24	Core Worlds	3.00	tbd	3	3				4		Keri - 2
23	Lords of Waterdeep	4.00	tbd	5	4				3		Keri - 4
22	Bora Bora	4.75	tbd	5	4				5		Keri - 5
21	Rise of Augustus	3.25	tbd	3	3				4		Keri - 3
20	Settlers of Catan	2.25	tbd	3	2				1		Keri - 3
19	Rampage/Terror in Meeple City	4.00	tbd	3	3/5				5		Keri - 4
18	Dominion	5.00	tbd	6	4/6				4		Keri - 4
18	Trains	3.00	tbd	3	3				3		Keri - 3
17	Amerigo	4.50	tbd	4	5				5		Keri - 4
16	City of Iron	3.00	tbd	3	3				3		Keri - 3
15	Voluspa	4.75	up	6	4				3		Keri - 6
15	Tash Kalar	3.75	up	4	4				4		Keri - 3
14	Steam Park	4.17	down	5	2/3				5	a	Keri - 5
13	Seasons	4.25	up	4	5				3		Keri - 5
12	Lost Legends	2.17	flat	2	2/3				2		Keri - 1
11	Keyflower	3.92	down	3	3/4				5		Keri - 2
10	Cosmic Encounter	5.25	up	5	5				6		Keri - 5
09	Nothing Personal	4.50	n/a	6	5				4		Keri - 5
08	Divinare	3.50	n/a	3	3				4		Keri - 4
08	Escape: The Curse of the Temple	4.00	n/a	5	2				5		Keri - 4
07	Galaxy Trucker	5.50	n/a	6	5				5		Keri - 6
06	Bruges	5.75	up	5	6				6		Keri - 5
05	Via Appia	3.17	n/a	3	2/3				4		Keri - 4
04	Libertalia	5.00	n/a	5	5				5		Keri - 5
04	Dungeon Roll	4.00	n/a	4	4				5		Keri - 3
03	Ghost Stories	3.50	n/a	4	3				5		Keri - 2
02	Smash Up	1.50	n/a	0	2				1		Keri - 2/4
01	King of Tokyo	4.25	n/a	5	4				3		Keri - 5