Rating Summaries

Each episode we rate one (and sometimes 2) games on the Blue Peg, Pink Peg rating system.

0 Pegs = Burn It, 1 Peg = Avoid It, 2 Pegs = Not Horrible, 3 Pegs = Worth Playing, 4 Pegs = Worth Owning, 5 Pegs = A Collection Asset, 6 Pegs = A Collection Essential.

Reviewers: C = Christina, J =  Jeremy, R = Robb, P = Patrick, Jo = Josh, Guest = Guest reviewer.

Click on any of the game titles to see when the game has appeared in the show.

Ep.GameAverageRerollC.J.R.P.Jo.Guest
168Cooper Island4.75n/a554/5n/an/an/a
1677 Souls3.75n/a4533n/an/a
166Oceans3.33n/a424n/an/an/a
165Sierra West3.00n/a333n/an/an/a
164Isle of Cats3.67n/a434n/an/an/a
163Sorcerer City4.66n/a644n/an/an/a
162Maracaibo4.00n/a4255n/an/a
161The Taverns of Tiefenthal4.33n/a544n/an/an/a
160A War of Whispers3.00n/a333n/an/an/a
159Rune Stones4.00n/a435n/an/an/a
158Flotilla4.66n/a455n/an/an/a
157Abomination: Heir of Frankenstein2.66n/a323n/an/an/a
156Horrified4.50n/a455n/a4n/a
155Rurik4.00n/a534n/an/an/a
154Dead Man's Cabal4.00n/a444n/an/an/a
153The Artemis Project3.50n/a4343n/an/a
152Chronicles of Crime4.75n/a5644n/an/a
151Rolled West3.75n/a4434n/an/a
151Lanterns Dice3.00n/a4233n/an/a
151Cartographers5.00n/a5555n/an/a
150Pipeline3.75n/a4434n/an/a
148Journeys in Middle Earth4.00n/a4444n/an/a
147Gentes4.50n/a5544n/an/a
146Tiny Towns3.58n/a333/43n/an/a
145Tudor2.75n/a2234n/an/a
144Treasure Island2.75n/a4322n/an/a
143Forum Trajanum3.25n/a3244n/an/a
142Teotihuacan: City of Gods4.75flat6544n/an/a
141Gugong3.00up4233n/an/a
140But Wait, There's More!4.67downn/an/a54n/aBruce - 5
140Pantone1.67downn/an/a21n/aBruce - 2
140Just One5.33upn/an/a55n/aBruce - 6
139Quacks of Quedlinburg4.00up5344n/an/a
138Blackout: Hong Kong4.75down5455n/an/a
137Coimbra6.00down6666n/aDanny - 6
136Pulsar 28494.40flat5444n/aDavid - 5
135Porta Nigra4.30flat4544n/aJames - 4/5
134Feudum4.50flat4554n/an/a
133The Thing: Infection at Outpost 312.50down3232n/an/a
132Nyctophobia: Vampire Encounter3.25flat4513n/an/a
132Sub Terra2.50flat322/42n/an/a
131Detective: A Modern Crime Board Game4.67down6n/a44n/an/a
130Root4.33down4n/a45n/an/a
129Gunkimono3.67flat4 n/a43n/an/a
129Expancity4.00flat4n/a44n/an/a
129Spring Meadow2.67flat4n/a22n/an/a
128Petrichor3.33down3n/a43n/an/a
127Thunderstone Quest5.00down4n/a556n/a
126Carthago3.25flat3n/a433n/a
125Crystal Clans4.25down4n/a544n/a
125The Fox in the Forest3.25down3n/a433n/a
125Santorini3.50flat4n/a352n/a
124Argent: The Consortium5.00down4n/a555n/a
123Trajan5.00flat5n/a564n/a
122Altiplano3.75flat4n/a443n/a
121Heroes of Land, Sea and Air4.00flat4n/a444n/a
120Dinosaur Island4.00down4n/a332n/a
119Rising Sun5.00down5n/a555n/a
118Clans of Caledonia4.40down4/5n/a454n/a
117Calimala4.00flat4n/a543n/a
116Raiders of the North Sea4.00flat4n/a444n/a
115Rajas of the Ganges3.75flat4n/a443n/a
114Lisboa5.00flat4n/a56n/an/a
113Stuffed Fables4.76down4n/a3/55n/aRodney - 3/5
112Whistle Stop4.20down4n/a45n/aMarty & Tony - 4
111Valletta2.88down3n/a32n/aStephanie - 3/4
110Custom Heroes5.67flat6n/a65n/an/a
110Trickster: Champion of Time5.00flat5n/a55n/an/a
110Indulgence3.33down3n/a34n/an/a
109Mansions of Madness 2nd. Ed5.00up5654n/an/a
108Fate of the Elder Gods4.50flat4545n/an/a
107Ex Libris3.33down43n/a3n/an/a
106Lorenzo il Magnifico4.25flat4544n/an/a
104Sentient4.50flat5544n/an/a
103Wasteland Express Delivery Service5.00down4655n/an/a
102Barenpark3.00down332/43n/an/a
99Aeon's End3.50flat4244n/an/a
98Yokohama4.75flat5545n/an/a
97Viticulture4.80flat4545n/aPeghead Sean - 6
96Railroad Revolution4.50down5544n/an/a
94Adrenaline2.86down332/33n/an/a
93Clank!4.75flat5545n/an/a
92Barcelona: The Rose of Fire4.50flat4545n/an/a
91Manhattan Project: Energy Empire4.00down4235n/aPeghead Steve - 6
90The Oracle of Delphi3.50down4343n/an/a
89Great Western Trail4.25up4544n/an/a
88Tikal4.40flat4435n/aPeghead Tahsin - 4
87Haspelknecht3.25down3334n/an/a
86Terraforming Mars5.50up6655n/an/a
85Mystic Vale4.50 flat5544n/an/a
84The Others3.50flat4343n/an/a
83Salem3.25down342/43n/an/a
82Scythe3.75up4533n/an/a
81Inis3.75down4344n/an/a
80Cry Havoc4.00flat4345n/an/a
79Junk Art3.75down4245n/an/a
78My Village3.75flat4344n/an/a
77Millennium Blades4.75flat4555n/an/a
76The Networks3.25down4324n/an/a
75Isle of Skye4.00up5443n/an/a
74Antarctica4.00down4534n/an/a
73Seven Wonders: Duel2.75up4322n/an/a
73The Rose King4.75flat5554n/an/a
73Thunder & Lightning4.75up4456n/an/a
73Tides of Time3.00down1335n/an/a
72Castles of Burgundy5.66up6n/a56n/an/a
71The Prodigals Club5.00down55n/a5n/an/a
70Mombasa4.50up4545n/an/a
69Shakespeare2.55down3232n/an/a
68Grand Austria Hotel3.88down443/44n/an/a
67Kingdom Death: Monster2.75flat4052n/an/a
66Dark Moon4.50flat4635n/an/a
65Orleans4.25up4445n/an/a
64Tail Feathers3.25down3424n/an/a
63Star Wars: Imperial Assault4.00flat4444n/an/a
62The Golden Ages3.25flat3334n/an/a
61Pandemic Legacy: Season 14.50down543/55n/an/a
60Above and Below4.00down4534n/an/a
59Dark, Darker, Darkest1.25down1220n/an/a
58Dead of Winter4.25down4544n/an/a
57Blood Rage4.50flat4545n/an/a
56Rattle, Battle, Grab the Loot2.00flat2222n/an/a
55Viceroy3.00n/a3333n/an/a
54La Granja5.25flat5646n/an/a
53Eysium3.38down423/44n/an/a
52[redacted]1.75flat2212n/an/a
51Terra Mystica5.25up4566n/an/a
50Staufer Dynasty4.58down543/45n/an/a
49Panamax4.00down3544n/an/a
48Murano3.25flat3334n/an/a
47Pathfinder ACG2.75up312/53n/an/a
47Descent 2nd Ed.3.50down3344n/an/a
46Patchistory4.33upn/a444n/an/a
45St. Petersburg4.25flat4544n/an/a
44Deus4.00up4345n/an/a
43Castles of Mad King Ludwig4.75flat6256n/an/a
42CO24.00flat4444n/an/a
41Scoville3.50down342/43n/an/a
40Kingsport Festival3.25down3523n/an/a
39Chimera4.25flat4346n/an/a
39Diamonds4.50down4545n/an/a
38Concordia4.25up3545n/an/a
37Abyss3.75flat3444n/an/a
36Legacy: The Testament of Duke de Crecy3.50flat3344n/an/a
35Battle at Kemble's Cascade4.00down4n/a4/25n/aKeri - 4
34Fiasco3.50up4n/a43n/aKeri - 3
34Elder Sign3.00up3n/a33n/aKeri - 3
33Zombie 151.33flatn/an/a11n/aKeri - 2
32Among the Stars3.75flat4n/a44n/aKeri - 2/4
31Five Tribes5.00up5n/a46n/aKeri - 5
30Machi Koro3.25down3n/a24n/aKeri - 4
30Pandemic Contagion2.75flat3n/a23n/aKeri - 3
29Enigma3.875up4n/a1/44n/aKeri - 5
29Macao3.750flat4n/a53n/aKeri - 3
28Instanbul3.250flat2n/a34n/aKeri - 4
27Splendor3.625up4n/a3/43n/aKeri - 4
27Blueprints3.00down3n/a33n/aKeri - 3
26Blue Moon Legends5.00tbd5n/a45n/aKeri - 6
25Sentinels of the Multiverse2.63tbd1/4n/a23n/aKeri - 2
24Core Worlds3.00tbd3n/a34n/aKeri - 2
24Bruxelles 18934.50tbd4n/a55n/aKeri - 4
23Lords of Waterdeep4.00tbd5n/a43n/aKeri - 4
22Bora Bora4.75tbd5n/a45n/aKeri - 5
21Rise of Augustus3.25tbd3n/a34n/aKeri - 3
20Settlers of Catan2.25tbd3n/a21n/aKeri - 3
19Rampage/Terror in Meeple City4.00tbd3n/a3/55n/aKeri - 4
18Dominion4.75tbd6n/a4/64n/aKeri - 4
18Trains3.00tbd3n/a33n/aKeri - 3
17Amerigo4.50tbd4n/a55n/aKeri - 4
16City of Iron3.00tbd3n/a33n/aKeri - 3
15Voluspa4.75up6n/a43n/aKeri - 6
15Tash Kalar3.75up4n/a44n/aKeri - 3
14Steam Park4.38down5n/a2/35n/aKeri - 5
13Seasons4.25up4n/a53n/aKeri - 5
12Lost Legends1.88flat2n/a2/32n/aKeri - 1
11Keyflower3.36down3n/a3/45n/aKeri - 2
10Cosmic Encounter5.25up5n/a56n/aKeri - 5
09Nothing Personal4.50n/a6n/a54n/aKeri - 5
08Divinare3.50n/a3n/a34n/aKeri - 4
08Escape: The Curse of the Temple4.00n/a5n/a25n/aKeri - 4
07Galaxy Trucker5.50n/a6n/a55n/aKeri - 6
06Bruges5.75up5n/a66n/aKeri - 5
05Via Appia3.36n/a3n/a2/34n/aKeri - 4
04Dungeon Roll4.00n/a4n/a45n/aKeri - 3
04Libertalia5.00n/a5n/a55n/aKeri - 5
03Ghost Stories3.50n/a4n/a35n/aKeri - 2
02Smash Up1.50n/a0n/a21n/aKeri - 2/4
01King of Tokyo4.25n/a5n/a43n/aKeri - 5